Prof. Erica Chenoweth |
I particularly liked the presentation given by Prof. Erica Chenoweth at that conference. I found it so compelling, I tweeted the key points, just as fast as I could type. You can watch the Chenoweth presentation here, or just read my notes below!
Basic findings
* Want to know which works better - #nonviolence or #violence? COUNT! (Retweet this.)
* Using the strictest measures - the #nonviolence approach still tallies more successes! (Retweet this.)
* "I was blown away" - the #nonviolence approach more successful by 2:1 margin! (Retweet this.)
* #Nonviolence #resistance works. (Even if YOU don't believe it!) (Retweet this.)
How nonviolence works
* #INCLUSION - #nonviolence campaigns work - 'cause they get more PEOPLE involved! (Retweet this.)
* in face of state #violence, #nonviolence #resistance actually gets MORE people involved (Retweet this.)
* (Put another way: #nonviolence is the way to get beyond "just males" protest) (Retweet this.)
* "looks like a party" ... "safety in numbers" ... [ ..... reach the tipping point!] (Retweet this.)
* fewer barriers to entry ... possibility of exit ... means MANY more participate (Retweet this.)
* Don't discount #moral factor: average person doesn't want to injure ( even in #army!) (Retweet this.)
BIG campaigns
* Q: What's the big deal about BIG campaigns? (Retweet this.)
* The bigger the campaign, the more it erodes "pillars of support" for power holders (Retweet this.)
* Big participation means you get inside heads of "instruments of repression" (#police) (Retweet this.)
* "Backfire" - even IF there's #violent repression, tends to ENCOURAGE more mass action! (Retweet this.)
* TWO big tools of #nonviolence #resistance: "concentration" AND "dispersion" (Retweet this.)
An example: IRAN
* Lessons of 100 days #revolution in #Iran - one of largest of all times (Retweet this.)
* Last 10 days of 100 days #revolution in #Iran - general strike, esp. #oil workers (Retweet this.)
* By end of 100 days #revolution in #Iran - even #POLICE were calling in sick (Retweet this.)
* #nonviolence campaigns TEN TIMES more likely to result in #democracy (measured at 5 yrs (Retweet this.)
Overcoming old myths
* all this contradicts MYTH: #nonviolence #resistance ineffective vs repressive opponents (Retweet this.)
* this ALSO contradicts MYTH: #nonviolence #resistance can't arise in closed society (Retweet this.)
* key MYTH to overcome: "little bit of #violence" helpful to (main) #nonviolence effort (Retweet this.)
* "little bit of #violence" PROBLEM #1: more generalized violence leads to lower participation (Retweet this.)
* if you're interested in #radical #change - look at the hard facts on what's worked w-w (Retweet this.)
Research challenges
* Research challenge #1: how can #minority movements draw in #majority? (Retweet this.)
* Research challenge #2: (indirect) #solidarity and #support: is it really contributing? (Retweet this.)
* Research challenge #3: what #leadership structure REALLY works? (Retweet this.)
* Research challenge #4: civil resistance in #war zones - e.g. #Iraq #Syria #Afghanistan (Retweet this.)
Taking this information to the wider world
* Big surprise: how ANGRY people get about #nonviolence! (vs. #violence) (Retweet this.)
* We're talking #paradigm shift! (Like Thomas Kuhn on #revolution in #science!) (Retweet this.)
* (PS - people's response to #Galileo was: KILL HIM!) (Retweet this.)
* "We must unlearn what we have learned." (Yoda) (Retweet this.)
* Maybe it's a problem of learning styles? (video vs text?) (Retweet this.)
* Teachers: ask for re-evaluation of #textbooks (eg #USA #history) (Retweet this.)
* #USA #history: learn about MASS CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE underpinning #American #Revolution (Retweet this.)
RECAP: 4 attributes observed in successful #nonviolence resistance movement
* "Mass and diverse participation" (Retweet this.)
* "new techniques for #resistance" (Retweet this.)
* "obtain the defections of the elites" (Retweet this.)
* "maintain discipline in the face of repression" (Retweet this.)
FOR MORE: watch the full Chenoweth presentation here.
Related posts
This tweet seems perfectly timed because of what is about to happen in a few weeks in Chicago.
(See Nonviolent Direct Action to Stop Police Crimes: Effective? )
(See "The way to respond to ISIS is not through violence." )
Think about it:
Aircraft carriers and Tomahawk missiles.
Drums.
Where's the real violence?
(See War, War Protests, and "Technology" )
No comments:
Post a Comment